McCoy Insurance Agency
MENU
About Us
At McCoy Insurance Agency, we’ve been providing personalized insurance solutions to our neighbors in Wayne County for over a century.
Our family-owned agency is built on values of trust and integrity, with a mission to protect your family, farm, and business with reliable coverage. Whether you're a local business owner, a homeowner, or a farmer, we’ll work with you to ensure you have the protection you need, so you can focus on what you love.
Over the years, we’ve served hundreds of clients, and our commitment to each one is what makes us stand out.
Our Team
J. Matthew McCoy
President- Owner
P: 330-345-7220
Sarah Boreman
Manager - Agent
P: 330-345-7220
Jill Genet
Agent - Doylestown
P: 330-345-7220
Julie Yensho
Agent-Doylestown
P: 330-345-7220
Jodie Seager
Agent-Wooster
P: 330-345-7220
Linda Reese
CSR-Doylestown
P: 330-345-7220
How to Work with Us
1
Initial, No Cost Consultation
We start by getting to know you and your unique insurance needs. Whether you visit one of our offices or connect with us online or by phone, we’ll listen to your concerns and answer any questions you have. Please contact either of our locations to schedule a consultation either in person or by phone.
2
Personalized Insurance Review
Based on your consultation, we conduct a comprehensive review of your current insurance coverage (if applicable) and identify any gaps or opportunities for improvement. We then assess the right types of coverage for your family, business, or farm. To help expedite the review process, please provide your current insurance declaration page(s). Declaration (dec) Pages can be obtained from your current insurance agent, thru your current insurance company's website, or you can provide the paper copy that your insurance company sent out at the beginning of your insurance term.
3
Tailored Insurance Solutions
We partner with reputable insurance providers to offer a range of customized coverage options. From home and auto to business and farm insurance, we’ll present you with the best options tailored to your specific needs and budget.
4
Policy Selection & Implementation
Once you've selected the insurance package that’s right for you, we handle all the paperwork and make the process as seamless as possible. We ensure you understand your coverage and feel confident in your choices.
5
Ongoing Support & Service
Our relationship doesn’t end when your policy is in place. We provide ongoing support, whether it’s helping with claims, adjusting your coverage as your needs change, or answering any questions that come up. You can count on us for responsive, friendly service year after year.
WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY
“Super helpful and knowledgeable…they took the time to answer all my questions and then some!”
—Jennifer S.
WHAT CLIENTS SAY
I was in need of new auto insurance after recently purchasing my vehicle. A couple family members recommended me to McCoy insurance agency. Julie Yensho was phenomenal, she was able to get me more coverage than I previously had, additional coverage features, and provided exceptional customer service in the paperwork signing process. I was covered within 36hrs! I would highly recommend McCoy insurance agency if you’re looking for an agency who is willing to listen and provide coverages based on your insurance needs without trying to upsell/overcharge. Life long McCoy customer here! - AJ G.